White House counsel pushes back hard. The Gateway Pundit reports that White House Counsel Will Scharf told Democratic leaders in the House and Senate they “do not have the authority” to unilaterally launch investigations or demand documents as ranking members. The letter, described by TGP as sent Wednesday, followed Rep. Robert Garcia’s document-preservation letters to a dozen people, including members of former President Trump’s family and current and former administration officials.
What Scharf said, per TGP
According to The Gateway Pundit’s account of Scharf’s letter to “ranking members,” he criticized Democratic letters to executive branch officials that “imply, without evidence, that thousands of United States government employees are conspiring to destroy documents in violation of the Federal Records Act.” He also wrote the letters “drip with an animus or pettiness revealing that the purpose of these letters is not legitimate oversight but to harass and aggrandize.”

TGP says Scharf cited an executive branch policy that departments and agencies comply with congressional requests only after receiving “an authorized oversight request that is in furtherance of a legitimate legislative purpose.” He reportedly added: “Your demands do not reflect a request of the House, Senate, or a committee to which that body’s oversight authority has been delegated.”
Per the same report, Scharf argued that ranking-member requests in the 119th Congress “do not trigger any obligation” and “do not carry over” to the next Congress, adding, “This should not be surprising to you given the Biden Administration took the same position in 2022.”
Garcia’s preservation push
The Gateway Pundit reports that Garcia, who it says is set to chair the House Oversight Committee in the next Congress, sent preservation letters to 12 individuals. According to TGP’s recounting of a press release from Garcia’s office, the letters lay “the groundwork to advance investigations led by Oversight Democrats related to Trump family profiteering that may threaten the public interest, corporate corruption, misconduct at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), and the ongoing White House cover-up of the Jeffrey Epstein files.”
Threat of criminal investigations
TGP adds that last week Scharf warned Garcia that Democrats could face criminal investigations if they “abuse the legislative process.” In a letter quoted by The Gateway Pundit, Scharf wrote: “The Administration will not be extorted and will not be cowed by unlawful process motivated by animus, pettiness, hatred, or any other unlawful motive to intimidate, penalize, or interfere with the lawful functioning of government,” and referenced “blatant criminality.”
Claimed DOJ actions
According to The Gateway Pundit’s article, the Justice Department “has since opened several investigations and fired off preservation letters to various Democratic lawmakers for threatening members of the Trump administration, donors, and private citizens affiliated with President Trump.” Independent Minute has not verified this claim.
What compliance Scharf says is possible
TGP reports that Scharf wrote the White House will comply with lawful requests if Democrats hold majorities and chair committees, but only if requests are “made in furtherance of a legitimate legislative purpose.” He added that the White House’s commitment is “colored and qualified by the ‘pettiness’ promised by one potential incoming Chair,” per the passage quoted by TGP.

